MLB Power Rankings: Early Season Impact Players
By Grant Brisbee, Chad Jennings, and Levi Weaver
Updated weekly through the perspectives of local and national baseball writers, these rankings reflect team performances and key player contributions.
The start of a baseball season often comes with fluctuations in team performance that can surprise fans and analysts alike. As the 2025 MLB season enters its early weeks, it’s important to note that small sample sizes can significantly influence outcomes and perceptions, unlike in sports where a few decisive games can sway league standings.
This week’s power rankings reveal some expected results and a few early surprises, such as the unexpectedly strong showing from the San Francisco Giants and the struggles of the Atlanta Braves despite their previous strengths. As teams begin to establish their identities, we’ve identified one standout player from each team who is making a notable impact, either positively affecting current performance or shaping future expectations.
Leading Teams in Focus
1. Los Angeles Dodgers
Record: 9-3 | Last Rank: 1
Key Player: Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Despite injuries impacting their rotation, Yamamoto has emerged as a reliable starter, maintaining the Dodgers’ top position in the rankings.
2. Philadelphia Phillies
Record: 7-2 | Last Rank: T-4
Key Player: Jesús Luzardo
Luzardo’s spectacular starts, including a perfect outing against the Dodgers, have reaffirmed his vital role in the Phillies’ strong early season.
3. New York Yankees
Record: 6-4 | Last Rank: 2
Key Player: Aaron Judge
Judge’s early-season performance showcases his continued dominance, leading the league in runs and RBIs.
4. San Diego Padres
Record: 9-2 | Last Rank: 7
Key Player: Jackson Merrill
Merrill’s potential as a rising star is evident as he leads the team in RBIs, further solidifying the Padres’ offensive lineup.
5. Texas Rangers
Record: 8-3 | Last Rank: 3
Key Player: Josh Smith
Smith’s versatile defensive skills and offensive contributions have made a significant difference for the Rangers this season.
Mid-Tier Teams Making Moves
6. Arizona Diamondbacks
Record: 5-6 | Last Rank: 6
Key Player: Corbin Carroll
As Carroll starts to showcase his true potential, the Diamondbacks are eager for his growth to match their offensive expectations.
7. Boston Red Sox
Record: 6-5 | Last Rank: 8
Key Player: Rafael Devers
Devers’ hot streak has been directly correlated with the team’s recent winning ways, emphasizing his role as a premiere offensive player.
8. New York Mets
Record: 7-3 | Last Rank: 9
Key Player: Tylor Megill
With critical injuries affecting their rotation, Megill has stepped up, securing wins early in the season to stabilize the pitching staff.
9. San Francisco Giants
Record: 8-2 | Last Rank: 15
Key Player: Wilmer Flores
Flores’ early offensive contributions have helped the Giants achieve their fastest start since 2003, signaling a strong team effort.
Lower Tier Teams and Their Differentiators
10. Atlanta Braves
Record: 1-8 | Last Rank: T-4
Key Player: Spencer Strider
Strider’s potential return from the injured list could be pivotal, as the Braves struggle to find their footing early in the season.
11. Baltimore Orioles
Record: 5-6 | Last Rank: 10
Key Player: Charlie Morton
The struggle in the Orioles’ rotation has left Morton under scrutiny, as he looks to turn around a poor start to the season.
12. Chicago Cubs
Record: 8-5 | Last Rank: 13
Key Player: Kyle Tucker
Tucker’s impressive offensive numbers are garnering attention, showcasing his value in the Cubs’ early success.
13. Tampa Bay Rays
Record: 4-5 | Last Rank: 17
Key Player: Brandon Lowe
Lowe’s consistent offensive output has kept the team competitive, although the lineup remains inconsistent overall.
14. Kansas City Royals
Record: 5-5 | Last Rank: T-21
Key Player: Maikel García
As García showcases promising early stats, the Royals are optimistic about maintaining their competitive edge.